Panel Rundown: The Great Writers Blog

Posted on November 21, 2006
Filed Under conventions | 4 Comments

Place: Orycon 2006
Sunday, 12 PM
Panelists: Cory Doctorow, Jay Lake, Mary Robinette Kowal
Moderator: Me

Jay and Mary were both people that I met as we sat down at the table and people that I liked quite a bit. I had a chance to talk to both in hallways later on and carry on the conversation a little further. At the absolute last minutes, as I was leaving the con Mary and I chatted about her growing up in North Carolina. I suggested she try to make Converge South next year, but she lives in Iceland so that’s a big issue for her. She’s got the same difficulties as I do in going to lots of cross-country cons, except hers is far longer international flights.

To be perfectly honest, this is the panel I feared the most as a moderator. That Cory is a blogger of repute and reach that swamps out the other three of us I thought might be an issue. To his enormous credit, he did not pull rank or in any way condescend to the other panelists or anyone in the room. I found that highly classy and egalitarian, treating us all as equal peers and partners in the blogosphere and the present conversation.

I did some audience calibration to begin this panel. I asked for shows of hands for a number of questions: who wants to blog but doesn’t know how; who blogs; who writes or wants to write professionally; who writes and blogs; who uses their writing as a topic in or as snippets of their blog. There were only three people out of maybe 40 or 50 that were in the “need to learn” camp so I asked them to reraise their hands for someone knowledgeable near them to volunteer to buddy up with them and talk to them after the panel to help them out. Then we began.

Because I’m not a working writer I laid back for several swatches of time in the discussion, doing traffic control but not really adding much. The one thing I really wanted to throw out there was the story of my work blogging rules of the road and how I had the discussion up front before I blogged the first thing about my present company. Because people can and do get fired over this, I felt that dominating the conversation for a few minutes might be a necessary evil. I contended that getting fired over blogging is stupid, and your first responsibilities are to the bottom of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. Keeping you and your children fed is a higher priority than your post. As much as I love it and don’t want it removed from my life, I could live without blogging in a way that I couldn’t without food or shelter. Cory took exception to that and thinks I’m giving the act of self-expression short shrift but we have to agree to disagree on this. I think it’s the very definition of a higher level Maslowian act.

Mary had some fascinating stories about how she has used her blog for her artistic endeavors and also how she deals with the blog/work membrane. Cory talked about a common theme of the weekend – the collapse of multi-faceted identities to a single point and the problems that can cause when your home life is public and it make cause friction with your work life and how blogging can be the mechanism for that collapse. Jay and Cory both talked about using their blogs as repositories for their work in progress and the materials thereof. There was discussion of the “personal brand” and lots of talk about whether to have separate blogs for different topics, whether to be pseudonymous or use one’s real name. We talked about the blog as a tool for engagement with ones audience and the Neil Gaiman approach of chatty blogging vs the Neal Stephenson opproach of conspicuous absence from the web and blogosphere.

At the end, Cory tried to teach me something about moderation that I was just too slow on the uptake to do effectively this time but that I’ll be doing every panel I ever moderate from here on out. When we ran low on time, we got all the people with pending questions to just all ask them one at a time. Then we went down the row and each panelist answered one of the questions on the floor. It worked like gangbusters once I finally understood what we were trying to do. I thought that each question would get a volunteer to answer it, which was upside down from the real thing. At the panel he moderated he did this (much more smoothly) and it worked very very well.

Bottom Line: I enjoyed this panel a lot, learned a lot, was enlightened with a dose of reinvigoration for the value of what we do, and hope my moderation was as good as the topic, panel and audience deserved.

Tags: , , ,

Comments

There is a posted comment policy for this blog. Please respect the rules.

4 Responses to “Panel Rundown: The Great Writers Blog”

    Comment Permalink
  1. Dom Barnes on November 21st, 2006 9:04 am

    Glad to hear it all went well on that first panel. Look forward to hearing the interviews and the taped panels.

    Just been looking over some old posts. What does your usual travel bag include? I saw you used a portable device but wondered what you use? Whats your main travel machine, what can’t you live without on trips?

  2. Comment Permalink
  3. dave on November 21st, 2006 9:14 am

    Dom, this was actually the second to last panel. I’m not doing them in chronological order per se. I wrote most of that on the plane home because it wasn the one I was thinking about.

    When I get home I’ll inventory my bag as I unpack, how about that? I had two bags, my backpack with my laptop and books and such and then one duffel bag devoted almost exclusively to audio equipment It makes for a long day with sore shoulders, that’s for sure since I carried both around most of the con.

  4. Comment Permalink
  5. Dom Barnes on November 21st, 2006 9:56 am

    I should’ve gone back and read which panels you did when. Sorry bout that. Either way, nice to hear about it.
    I thought the idea of hooking up people who wanted to blog but didn’t know how to with people who would show them was a great idea. Its nice that you didn’t just leave them without information, you made sure someone was happy to give them a tutorial.
    I assume somewhere in those two bags you managed to squeeze in a change of clothes!

  6. Comment Permalink
  7. PJ Cabrera on November 22nd, 2006 1:34 pm

    Dave, thanks for the write up, I enjoyed it very much.

    I find the sci-fi and fantasy cons fascinating, but I haven’t been to one in ages, more than 12 years. Anything else you can write up or recordings you can put up will be greatly appreciated.